In a working paper Christian Wagner, a PhD Candidate at the School of New Media, Peking University takes a fresh look at who’s doing what to either fix or address rare earth dependability issues.
The paper focuses particularly on Europe’s shortcomings. Viz.: “The central thesis of this article is that Europe has maneuvered itself into a paradoxical nexus of moral-regulatory claims, geopolitical ambitions, and physical constraints that leads to strategic miscalculations.”
In a nutshell the process of rare earth extraction is a filthy, dangerous, polluting, energy hungry, water depleting and time consuming business (P.8 has some eye-popping specifics).
Nimby-ism the world over pushed this business into China and now the Nimbys seems shocked to find they’re so dependent on this one source. Europe has the talent, know how and raw material to grow their refining capacity so the bottleneck is not skill, it’s will.
Moreover, Europe has tied itself in a mass of environmental, labor and administrative red tape making projects of the complexity and scale of rare earth refining much harder. This is in stark contrast to plans announced in 2005 by Member states to spend U$900bn on defense until 2030, with no funds earmarked for rare earth refining. As the paper wryly points out none of the kit on the shopping list works without rare earths.
In contrast the U.S. has grabbed the bull by the horns and made the production of rare earths and the management of the whole process chain a security imperative and taken on the task at government level. Korea and Japan have started substitute, friend-shoring and recycling plans (but still rely on China for around 80% of their needs).
The paper concludes with suggestions for Europe in the short, medium and long term to address the issue. Looking through Mr. Wagner’s prescriptions though they seem to require more initiative and planning than Europe has hitherto shown so why a policy change will occur now is the obvious question?
A cynic might see a Europe happy to leave the U.S. to do the heavy lifting hoping to ride on the coat tails of that initiative in the future. How happy America will be to oblige with sales of these precious commodities in that circumstance and in time we can only surmise.
You can read the paper in full via this link Europe’s Rare Earth Paradox.
Happy Sunday.